Alternately candid, funny, poignant and heartbreaking, this documentary focuses on a cross-section of men and women of all ages who invoke the exact moment in their lives--whether as toddlers, grade-schoolers, teens or young adults--when they knew, once and for all, that they were gay. Inspired by the work of writer Robert Trachtenberg, award-winning filmmakers Fenton Bailey and Randy Barbato set out across the country to interview these men and woman of all ages and walks of life and ask them a single, simple question: When did you know?
Fenton Bailey
Director
Randy Barbato
Director

Jeffrey Patrick Olson
Himself
Ashley Arnold
Young Teenage Girl
Melissa Marie Gibson
Teenage Girl #
James Evans
Homophobic Father
Charlene Geisler
Kid # 1
Disclosure78%
McQueen74%
The Class of ‘9271%
A Plastic Ocean75%
56 Up72%
Welcome to Chechnya69%
Being James Bond77%
Seduced and Abandoned62%
John Candy: I Like Me78%
Directed by John Ford70%
Love, Antosha74%
Sherman's March67%
Public Speaking70%
Western Stars70%
Iron Maiden: Burning Ambition86%
28 Up75%
Tongues Untied66%
The Summers of It - Chapter Two: It Ends71%
50 Greatest Harry Potter Moments74%
The Carter Effect70%