Michelle Carlsen (nee Deighton, born December 8, 1985) is a former American model and wrestler.

Deighton first competed on Cycle 4 of America's Next Top Model, where she placed sixth. After the show signed with the Janice Dickinson modelling agency. She has modeled for Elate Wear, Louche Clothing, Celebrity Baby Blog and Mommyground.com. Her runway credits include Meghan Spring and ElleGirl presents Dare To Be You: Wal-Mart Meets America's Next Top Models in 2005.

Deighton married fellow reality star, Jonny Fairplay from Survivor, in 2008. with whom she had a child named Piper Addison, who will be one year old on Jan. 16, 2009. The couple later divorced.