How would you protect someone from their first love?
A man tries to warn his brother away from the new girlfriend he brings home during Thanksgiving, but ends up becoming infatuated with her in the process.
Lee Toland Krieger
Director, Writer

Adam Scott
Caleb Sinclaire

Brittany Snow
Emma Gainsborough

Alex Frost
Peter Sinclaire

J.K. Simmons
Donald Sinclaire
Vittorio Brahm
J.T.

Bill Buell
Rocky

Alysia Reiner
Samantha
Kate Krieger
Molly

Jordan Reid
Hannah
Happiness74%
Friendship64%
American Beauty79%
Addicted59%
Careful What You Wish For61%
Diary of a Mad Housewife62%
May December65%
The Overnight59%
Landline61%
Snack Shack71%
Shame69%
Code 370%
From Straight A's to XXX58%
Deep Water58%
Almost Friends63%
Hallam Foe66%
Nightmare Alley69%
Sweetie60%
Die My Love61%
The Last American Virgin65%