Movies
TV Shows
People
10/04/1968 Drama, History, War 2h 19m
61
User score

Theirs is not to reason why...

Overview

During the Crimean War between Britain and Russia in the 1850s, a British cavalry division, led by the overbearing Lord Cardigan, engages in an infamously reckless strategic debacle against a Russian artillery battery.

  1. Tony Richardson

    Director

  2. John Osborne

    Writer

  3. Charles Wood

    Writer

Top billed cast

  1. Trevor Howard

    Lord Cardigan

  2. Vanessa Redgrave

    Mrs Clarissa Morris

  3. John Gielgud

    Lord Raglan

  4. Harry Andrews

    Lord Lucan

  5. Jill Bennett

    Mrs. Fanny Duberly

  6. David Hemmings

    Capt. Louis Edward Nolan

  7. Ben Aris

    Lt. Maxse

  8. Micky Baker

    Trooper Metcalfe

  9. Peter Bowles

    Paymaster Capt. Duberly

  10. View more

Full Cast & Crew

Reviews

A review by CinemaSerf
Written by CinemaSerf on 2025-06-07
If you’re looking for Errol Flynn and David Niven here, then you’ll be disappointed. Unlike the Hollywood version of the story from 1936, this one focuses far more on a critique on the command and control structures in the British Army at the start of the Crimean War. It’s principle target is Lord Cardigan (Trevor Howard) who is portrayed as an arrogant and frequently drunken sot without the skills to command himself much less others and one reeking with upper-class entitlement. Unfortunately for the young “Capt. Nolan” (David Hemmings), he manages to upset his commanding general and...read the rest
Read All Reviews

Recommendations

  1. Sergeant York72%
  2. The Four Feathers71%
  3. War Horse73%
  4. Lawrence of Arabia79%
  5. The Last of the Mohicans73%
  6. The Guns of Navarone73%
  7. Operation Mincemeat65%
  8. Gettysburg69%
  9. Taking Chance71%
  10. The Longest Day76%
  11. Khartoum63%
  12. King Arthur63%
  13. Devotion70%
  14. Courage Under Fire65%
  15. Breaker Morant70%
  16. The Birth of a Nation60%
  17. The Lost Battalion68%
  18. Palestine 3678%
  19. Gods and Generals63%
  20. Unconquered65%